Eleven states and the district of columbia, representing 165 electoral votes, have already passed legislation to have their electors vote for the winner of the national popular vote the agreement, known as the national popular vote interstate compact, would take effect once states representing a majority of. Research on the us electoral college including pro and cons arguments for keeping it in presidential elections. Since then, the electoral college issue has been debated, especially in election years when presidential candidates have won the popular vote but lost in the electoral college as part of our next 10 amendments project, we've asked constitution daily readers to give us their opinions on possible new. It has not taken effect because the number of electoral votes nationwide must exceed 270, but has reached only 165, according to a fiscal impact report given the past failures of proposed constitutional amendments seeking to eliminate the electoral college, a compact between states seems like the best. Sticking with the electoral college system, but not yet plunging into the surprising too-little-discussed history of why the framers put it in the which candidate they supported for president and which for vice president, thereby eliminating the possibility that any presidential candidate will end up in a tie with.
Discover how the electoral college works, read about its history, and learn about some of the problems of the electoral system in this grolier article about the electoral. In place in nebraska in maine3 those who wish to eliminate or substantially modify the electoral college, usually begin by noting that the original justification for its existence, the designation of sets of knowledgeable individuals who will meet in isolation in their respective states to deliberate and to make informed choices,. To reform or eliminate the electoral college system indeed, there have been more proposals for constitutional amendments to alter or abolish the electoral college than on any other subject the drive toward reform is understandable given the perceived impact on the democratic process and economic policy for example.
Today, in every state except nebraska and maine, whichever candidate wins the most votes in a state wins all the electors from that state, no matter what the margin of victory just look at the impact this system had on the 2016 race: donald trump won pennsylvania and florida by a combined margin of. The compact is designed to ensure that the candidate who wins the most popular votes is elected president, and it will come into effect only when it will guarantee that outcome as of 2016, it has been joined by ten states and the district of columbia their 165 combined electoral votes amount to 307%. The aclu has opposed the electoral college since 1969 for non-partisan reasons by now — everyone, republicans, democrats, and none-of-the-aboves — should be fed up with its undemocratic and unpredictable nature unfortunately, amending the constitution to eliminate this atavistic system is a.
Such an amendment would eliminate several extensive parts of the constitution, including article ii, section 1, ¶ 2, 4, and portions of the 12th, the 20th opponents of the electoral college complain that a third-party president can never be elected so long as the present system remains in effect19 they. As the voting public has evolved and become more knowledgeable, the outcry against the electoral college has never abated according to the national archives, the past 200 years have brought more than 700 proposed constitutional amendments to either “reform or eliminate” the electoral college. The electoral college is responsible for disenfranchising, in effect, huge swaths of american voters, said doug mcadam, a professor of sociology who studies eliminating the electoral college would empower voters, mcadam said, likely driving up voter registration and voting rates while creating a greater.
What impact does a candidate's concession speech have on the electoral college process how many times has the vice reference sources indicate that over the past 200 years, over 700 proposals have been introduced in congress to reform or eliminate the electoral college there have been more proposals for. There have, in its 200 year history, been a number of critics and proposed reforms to the electoral college system - most of them trying to eliminate it but there are one effect of this mechanism is to make it extremely difficult for third party or independent candidates ever to make much of a showing in the electoral college. All about super delegates, the electoral college and how trump can clinch nomination before california even votes though the democrats won the next election, with jimmy carter (thanks, in large part, due to the residual effects of the watergate scandal), they were squashed again four years later.
A growing number of americans — largely those who backed hillary clinton for president — are expressing frustration with the electoral college after it again evinced victory for the candidate who lost the popular vote as clinton's popular- vote margin over president-elect donald trump swells to more than. Seeking to cut into democrats' advantage, the plan would eliminate winner-take- all elections and allocate electoral votes based on congressional districts any changes to the allocation of electoral college votes would have a major impact on each party's path to the white house eighteen states and the. We're halfway to eliminating the electoral college keith wagstaff joe biden and john boehner conducting the official count of the electoral college at the start of the new year all of which is to say that one of two things needs to happen if the national popular vote is going to come into effect.
The electoral college was created for and serves the smaller states, and increases the impact those states can have in elections absent that system, candidates would simply court the larger states and population centers, says larry pope, a professor of constitutional law at drake university law school in. If the electoral college were eliminated, presidential candidates would focus only on highly populated areas rural areas that are less populated would be ignored, because, as a whole, these areas would have less impact on the election another reason to keep it is that with the electoral college we have. A campaign to eliminate the electoral college and “let the people elect the president,” is gaining steam a group called states with electoral votes totaling 270 of the 538 electoral votes would have to pass npv bills before the compact kicks in and any state's bill could take effect as usual, it's easy to get.
Isn't an amendment to eliminate the electoral college the next logical step emphatically, no a little education reveals the truth: the founders had sound, principled reasons for creating the electoral college a bare, emotional majority could enact any law it wanted to, regardless of its impact on the rest of the country. Professor don sharpes (opinion, dec 18) offers an interesting revisit to the federal convention of 1787 as he seeks a better way to select our presidents while i fully agree that we have ended up with “a man widely acknowledged as unfit for the presidency and unrepresentative of the nation's values and. The electoral college is one of the most dangerous institutions in american politics today the primary impact of the electoral college is to give the citizens of some states more influence over the presidential election than citizens of other states if you live in a battleground state you are showered with.